Immiserizing Growth Fails the Poor Theory and Empirical Research

Immiserizing Growth Fails the Poor refers to situations where economic growth does not lead to poverty reduction. How should this phenomenon be conceptualized? How often, when, and where does it occur? Why does it occur? Shaffer addresses these three sets of questions drawing on a wide range of theoretical perspectives and empirical approaches. This volume presents a conceptualization of immiserizing growth which combines the notions of failed and malevolent inclusion, being bypassed, and 'avoidably' harmed by growth, respectively. It develops this concept of malevolent inclusion drawing on a debate in philosophy about 'doing and allowing harm'. The analysis proceeds to examine the characteristics and causes of immiserizing growth on the basis of comparable household survey data from the 1990s using multiple poverty lines and time periods, and different measures of growth and poverty. The book also explores theories, processes, and mechanisms of immiserizing growth found in a wide variety of bodies of thought including the classical tradition of political economy (Mathus, Ricardo, and Marx), more recent radical traditions of scholarship, literatures on poverty dynamics, and inclusive growth and empirical case studies. It proceeds to empirically investigate some of the variables uncovered in this literature using cross-country econometric techniques, methods of qualitative comparative analysis and case-studies from sub-Saharan Africa, matched using cluster analysis and situated within a typological framework.

1 - Introduction
2 - Conceptual Framework: Failed and Malevolent Inclusion
3 - Historical Origins: Malthus, Ricardo, and Marx
4 - Contemporary Contributions: Processes and Mechanisms
5 - Cross Country Econometric Analysis
6 - Cross Country Qualitative Comparative Analysis
7 - Typology Construction for Case Study Selection
8 - Case Studies
9 - Conclusion

Paul Shafer is a Professor of International Development Studies at Trent University, Canada. His work focuses on poverty in the Global South on which he has published widely. He is the author of Q-Squared: Combining Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches in Poverty Analysis (2013) and co-editor of Immiserizing Growth: When Growth Fails the Poor (2019), both by Oxford University Press.